Search
Most Popular Articles
- Discussion of the Human Body Defense System
- The story of the 12 animals zodiac in China
- How to Balance Your Body to Get Pregnant
- How To Stop Your Cat Scratching - Get Rid Of Those Fleas
- Eating Junk Food -- The Hidden Price
- Ski Boots -- Testing 1, 2, 3
- Wear it Up or Wear it Down?
- Cat Care, Cat Products and Cat Diseases
- Choosing a Cell Phone
- Artificial Satellite Types
Roe v. Wade
 Category |
: Legal Matters |
 Times Read |
: 25 |
 Date |
: 12 July 2008 07:00 |
by: 4LawSchool.com
, 410 U.S. 113 (1973), is one of Supreme Courts most popular and controversial rulings. This article provides a summary of this decision.
Facts: The great state of Texas had a law which made it illegal to procure abortion unless the life of the mother was threatened by the pregnancy. The plaintiff (a pregnant woman) claimed that this law violated her constitutional rights.
Procedure: The District court provided declaratory relief to P by holding the law unconstitutional under the Ninth Amendment.
Issue: Does the P have a constitutional right to terminate her pregnancy?
Holding: Yes- but right not absolute.
Rationale (Blackmun): According to the court, the right of privacy under the 14th Amendment is broad enough to encompass a womans decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy. The court further ruled that the right of the woman is not absolute. The state can regulate the womans actions in cases where the law serves a compelling state interest. The court rejected Texas argument that at conception, the unborn should be considered a person under the Constitution. According to the court, the word person as used in the Constitution does not refer to the unborn. Therefore, in the end, the court ruled that in the initial stages of the pregnancy (before the end of the first trimester) the woman and her physician are free to make their choice about abortion without the interference from the state. For the subsequent stage of pregnancy, the state can regulate the womans choice but only to serve the compelling interest of promoting the health of the mother. For the stage after viability, the state in promoting its interest in the potentiality of human life may, if it chooses, regulate and even proscribe, abortion except where it is necessary to preserve the life of the mother.
Concurrence (Stewart): Even though the court in Griswold tried to avoid the substantive due process, it is clear that the case was decided based on this doctrine. The liberty protected by due process covers more than those freedoms explicitly named in the Bill of Rights. A woman enjoys the liberty to decide whether or not to terminate her pregnancy. But such liberty can be limited if the state shows a compelling interest (not just a legitimate interest).
Concurrence (Douglas): Three types of liberties: 1. Autonomous control over the development and expression of ones intellect, interests, tastes, and personality These right protected by 1st Amendment and are absolute. 2. Freedom of choice in the basic decision of ones life respecting marriage, divorce, procreation, contraception, and education. Not absolute and subject to some control by police power. 3. freedom to care for ones health and person, freedom from bodily restraint or compulsion, freedom to walk, stroll, or load. Subject to regulation on a showing of compelling state interest.
Dissent (Rehnquist): The fact that laws against abortion have existed for long time suggests that abortion is not so rooted in the traditions and conscience of our people as to be ranked as fundamental. Furthermore, the majoritys compelling interest requirement will take the court back to the Lochner era when the court acted more like a super legislature.
About The Author
4LawSchool.com is a legal portal with 1700+ case summaries, law school outlines and other legal research resources.
Random Article 1 |
Random Article 2 |
Asbestos is a dangerous and potentially deadly substance that was once widely used in a range of items, from ceiling and wall tiles to insulation and auto brakes. In the past, most people outside of the industry were totally unaware of the dangers relating to asbestos. However, over recent years the
|
Mans best friend can be mans worst enemy. Statistics show dog attacks have accounted for more than 300 dog-bite related deaths in the United States from the period of 1979 through 1996. Most of these victims were children. And someone seeks medical attention every forty seconds because of this bites
|
Random Article 3 |
Random Article 4 |
by: Maui Reyes According to the EEOC, 40% of all working women claim to have been sexually harassed at some point in their career. Obviously, sexual harassment, although deemed as taboo and obviously inappropriate behavior, occurs more often than we perceive it to be. If you or an |
by: Matthew Abts A Cup of Tea, Coffee, or Something Else www.quiettable.com Whenever investigating an individual or business, one of the most basic checks is for lawsuits, criminal charges, and bankruptcy filings. But how do you research the court system? Is there one simple site |
| indir teknolojix.com hiperucuz.com teknoloji forum The Most Beautiful Places hava kargo adtech ile reklam 2.0 dönemi ba?l?yor ve Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr r10.net seo yar??mas? |